How the baseball steak got its name
It's hard to resist a good steak. But simply ordering "a steak" isn't enough; the options seem endless. Each cut of steak differs in flavor, tenderness, and texture depending on the part of the cow it comes from. And with so many cuts available, it's not easy to know when to prepare each type.
It's hard to resist a good steak. But simply ordering "a steak" isn't enough; the options seem endless. Each cut of steak differs in flavor, tenderness, and texture depending on the part of the cow it comes from. And with so many cuts available, it's not easy to know when to prepare each type. To complicate matters further, there's one cut of steak that's frequently found in butcher shops that you've probably never heard of: the baseball steak.
The baseball steak gets its name from its shape. It's tall and round, so on the plate it slightly resembles a baseball. This steak is cut from the central, rounded portion of the tenderloin. The tenderloin is generally considered a tougher cut than, for example, the filet mignon, but with proper preparation, the baseball steak can be juicy and tender.
How to prepare a baseball steak
It's not always easy to understand what differentiates cuts of meat, but a baseball steak isn't as fatty as a ribeye and has less muscle than a sirloin, meaning it falls right in between the two in terms of tenderness. Because baseball steaks are so thick, the reverse sear method works well. This means cooking the steak in the oven first and searing it at the end, rather than searing it first. The oven method allows the center of the steak to cook slightly, so it can be seared for a shorter time without becoming overcooked.
Before baking, make sure the steak is well-seasoned. You can season it generously with just salt, or even brush it with a little olive oil and then rub it with a meat rub for a richer flavor. Since the baseball cut is about three inches thick, it's best to cook it slowly so it's rare. Heat it for at least 45 minutes at 275 degrees Fahrenheit; it could take up to an hour. Then, sear it on all sides in a cast-iron skillet with a little oil and finally brush it with a little butter.
