Butter extract versus flavoring: two completely different products
Butter extract, made with real butter, and synthetic flavoring that mimics its taste are very different products that serve different purposes in baking.
The butter-flavored popcorn at the movies uses flavoring, not real butter, because butter would melt quickly in a hot dispenser. The butter extract found in supermarkets, however, is derived from butter itself. The difference lies in how it's made and what ingredients are used.
Butter extract is made from the actual product through a process in which whole butter is combined with a liquid solvent (usually water or alcohol such as vodka) and then strained to remove the fat. This process concentrates the essential oils in the butter. Flavoring is a synthetic product designed to mimic the taste of butter, created during the manufacture of processed foods by isolating certain compounds present in butter. Some flavorings are made with natural ingredients obtained through roasting or distillation; most contain at least some artificial ingredients.
Because these compounds have been isolated and concentrated, the flavoring is usually more intense than real butter, which explains how the smell of popcorn lingers in a building all day. Butter extract is milder, with a more complex flavor due to the high concentration of natural butter compounds.
Similar to vanilla extract, butter extract is preferred for baking and making buttercream and other products. However, many extracts are made with alcohol, so the final product often contains traces of it. Flavorings do not tolerate heat well and are primarily used in margarines or oil-based spreads, helping commercially baked goods last longer.
